“Everyone knows you are the one who will fail first, and worst, if the three of you set out to seek your fortune.”

Sophie Hatter is introduced as the eldest daughter. Sophie expects to fail to succeed in life or acquire a fortune greater than the one she was born with because she believes the eldest daughter will always fail in doing so.

“But she wanted to do something – she was not sure what – that had a bit more interest to it than simply trimming hats.”

As Sophie begins her apprenticeship in the hat shop, she is quickly disappointed by the isolated and monotonous life she sees before her. She does not believe she is entitled to a more exciting life because of her destiny as the eldest sister: She will ultimately fail to seek a fortune.

“I’ve heard of you, Miss Hatter, and I don’t care for your competition or your attitude. I came to put a stop to you.”

The Witch of the Waste casts a spell on Sophie out of jealousy for her presumed closeness to Howl, though Sophie does not know the reason behind the Witch’s actions. Following the curse, Sophie’s appearance turns into that of an old woman and confirms her fear of living a misfortunate life.