Everyone Brave Is Forgiven

Everyone Brave Is Forgiven is a 2016 historical fiction novel by British writer and journalist Chris Cleave. Set in London during World War II, the novel explores the privilege and entitlement of wealthy Westerners confronted with the sudden brutality and loss of war through characters based somewhat on Cleave’s own grandparents.

The story opens at the moment England declares war on Germany. Wealthy eighteen-year-old Mary North, who’s skiing in Mont-Choisi, immediately quits finishing school and signs up to assist the war effort by wiring the War Office then taking a boat home without even changing clothes. She presents herself at the War Office and is assigned to be a teacher. Mary is initially excited about this position, but is deflated when she is informed that her initial duties are mainly to organize the children for evacuation. The children will be moved into homes in the country to avoid the inevitable bombings from the Germans.

Tom Shaw is introduced. He’s a twenty-three-year-old man working at the Education Ministry and living with his debonair, charming roommate and friend, Alastair Heath. Tom is convinced war will not actually break out despite the declaration, and he refuses to enlist. Tom argues cynically that someone has to stay behind and rebuild society, but Alastair has already enlisted.



Mary makes the best of her position and becomes friendly with her students, especially the sole American under her charge, a black child named Zachary Lee. To her anger and horror, she is fired from her position because she is judged to be overly familiar with the children; she detects a hint of bigotry and suspects it is because she treats Zachary in a friendly manner. She contacts Tom and appeals to him. Tom is immediately attracted to Mary and quickly secures her a new teaching position. He asks her out on a date and she accepts. Mary’s new work involves managing the children who cannot be relocated to the country—including Zachary, to her delight.

Alastair is deployed to France, where he sees violent action and becomes one of the hundreds of thousands of British soldiers stranded and rescued at Dunkirk. He returns to London and is promoted to captain. Tom and Mary invite Alastair and Mary’s friend Hilda out to dinner. Although Mary and Tom had hoped to fix up Alastair with Hilda—a flighty society girl obsessed with romance—Alastair is immediately attracted to Mary instead. Mary rebuffs his romantic advances out of loyalty to Tom.

The Blitz begins and London comes under brutal bombing. Alastair is sent to Malta to help defend the island against Axis powers. Tom, stunned by the violence of the bombing, finally attempts to enlist, but he is told his work is too important and his request is denied. One day, the school where Mary works is bombed, and several children and teachers are killed, leaving only Mary and Zachary alive.



Mary meets Hilda, who has volunteered with the ambulance corps, helping to ferry the injured to hospital. Hilda has matured and grown into a better person. Mary, now jobless, volunteers alongside her. While working with Hilda, Mary is injured and taken to the hospital herself, where she is treated and given morphine for the pain. She quickly becomes addicted to the drug, and Hilda stops seeing her as a result. Mary loses most of her connections, including Tom. She begins writing to Alastair, who is trapped in a siege at Malta amidst deteriorating conditions, and they conduct a flirtatious romantic relationship through letters.

Alastair has made a friend named Simonson in Malta, and the two protect each other and offer solace during their incredibly terrible experience there. When a German is taken prisoner, the collected anger of the people and soldiers coalesces into a mob desiring to tear the soldier limb from limb. Alastair attempts to protect the German prisoner from the mob, but the German bites his hand in the confusion and terror. The wound becomes infected, and eventually Alastair’s arm is amputated. Simonson arranges for Alastair to be evacuated off Malta before he is officially allowed to do so.

In London, Mary confesses her addiction to Zachary, and the boy helps her wean herself off the drug. Hilda visits and, seeing that Mary is sober, becomes her friend again. Alastair is imprisoned for going AWOL, but he’s released from prison and allowed to return to London, where he suggests that Hilda write to Simonson. American troops arrive in London, which gives Mary hope that the war will soon be over. She and Alastair spend time walking through the ruins of what was once a vibrant city, tentatively talking about a future together that they now believe might just be possible.